McGraw Hill Math: Intended to Confuse Parents and Students?
PLEASE DO NOT REPOST THIS ON THE BATS FB PAGE. It will be removed. Commentary became ugly; math is a touchy subject. Thank you.
Addendum 09-21-15: In this post, I question the quality of McGraw Hill’s math products. A parent came to me with the worksheet featured in this post. She said she and other adults could not figure out what the worksheet expected her son to do. The worksheet lacks adequate explanation and illustration, which is particularly important given that the term “regroup” is foreign to those who learned to “borrow.” This distinction might seem trivial, but terminology shapes paradigms. As a publisher, McGraw Hill should recognize this by including a stand-alone explanation/illustration on what is intended to be a worksheet of explanation.
In my post, I wonder whether McGraw Hill is trying to meld traditional math with CC math standards. I have had readers react strongly to this idea, stating that the varied ways of teaching math preceded (and are not unique to ) CC. However, CC was a virtually nationwide shift in math instruction forced upon teachers, students, and parents. This jolt has the public jumpy, which is all the more reason for math info purchased by districts and sent home as a homework help to be clear to parents.
This is a post about a fourth-grade assignment for a Louisiana student, and given that Louisiana is under Common Core for 2015-16, it is logical to conclude that the assignment below is McGraw Hill’s effort at a Common Core math assignment for fourth grade. (I write “effort” since the worksheet appears to try to offer traditional math and satisfy Common Core at the same time.)
The assignment is about carrying in subtraction. However, the explanation of how carrying works when one cannot borrow from the next column and must “borrow in order to borrow” is a lesson in frustration.
Interestingly, in July 2015, McGraw Hill decided to sell its summative (“high stakes”) testing division to Data Recognition Corp (DRC) and concentrate on classroom materials– like the math worksheet and online help featured in this post:
McGraw-Hill officials say leaving the summative and shelf testing markets will allow them to focus on products and services that more directly serve teachers and students in the classroom.
David Levin, McGraw-Hill Education’s president and CEO, said in an interview that the company’s major emphasis will be on “instructional materials, and the tools and software to make the most” of resources for students and teachers.
If we go back in time, to 2004, McGraw Hill intended to become “the leader in assessment reporting” as it acquired Common Core “architect” David Coleman’s assessment company, Grow Network, and kept Coleman on as CEO until 2007.
The best-laid assessment plans. Pity.
Let us now turn our attention to an example of the McGraw Hill math product: that fourth-grade worksheet in subtraction by carrying.
In characteristic Common Core math fashion, the explanation on the worksheet is confusing; it lacks detailed directions/illustration and therefore appears to require many parents to log in online for “homework help” (click on image to enlarge):
(The above reads like some effort to cross Common Core and traditional math. Here are the Common Core math standards for grade 4, “Number and Operations in Base Ten,” for those who wish to view and compare to McGraw Hill’s worksheet.)
But let us now leave McGraw Hill, for the explanation of the same concept, for example, on dummies.com under “How to Borrow when Subtracting” is much clearer:
In some cases, the column directly to the left may not have anything to lend. Suppose, for instance, you want to subtract 1,002 – 398. Beginning in the ones column, you find that you need to subtract 2 – 8. Because 2 is smaller than 8, you need to borrow from the next column to the left. But the digit in the tens column is a 0, so you can’t borrow from there because the cupboard is bare, so to speak:
When borrowing from the next column isn’t an option, you need to borrow from the nearest non-zero column to the left.
In this example, the column you need to borrow from is the thousands column. First, cross out the 1 and replace it with a 0. Then place a 1 in front of the 0 in the hundreds column:
Now, cross out the 10 and replace it with a 9. Place a 1 in front of the 0 in the tens column:
Finally, cross out the 10 in the tens column and replace it with a 9. Then place a 1 in front of the 2:
At last, you can begin subtracting in the ones column: 12 – 8 = 4:
Then subtract in the tens column: 9 – 9 = 0:
Then subtract in the hundreds column: 9 – 3 = 6:
Because nothing is left in the thousands column, you don’t need to subtract anything else. Therefore, 1,002 – 398 = 604.
In the spirit of promoting practical solutions necessary for efficiently navigating life, perhaps Louisiana school districts should ditch the expense of McGraw Hill and its Common Core confusion and invest in straightforward explanations.