Skip to content

Can Early AFT Endorsement of Clinton Save Her From Sanders and Benghazi?

July 13, 2015

On Saturday, July 11, 2015, the American Federation of Teachers (AFT) endorsed Hillary Clinton for the Democratic nomination for president.

This news is no surprise, and the AFT’s “long, deliberative process” is pretty much window dressing. It was going to be Hillary.

The July 11, 2015, AFT press release implies that AFT is supporting Clinton for president, but its own FAQ on the issue states that the endorsement is for the Democratic primary and that the vote to endorse Clinton for president has yet to occur:

Q: Is the endorsement only for the Democratic nomination? What about the general election?

A: Yes, the endorsement is for the Democratic nomination. The endorsement for the general election will be made by the delegates to the AFT convention, which will be held in July 2016 in Minneapolis.

So, the support is for the Democratic nomination, but Republicans were invited to vie for AFT support….

That AFT would endorse any Republican for president is unthinkable. AFT President Randi Weingarten “is an active member of the Democratic National Committee.” So, for AFT to state in its FAQ in the Hillary endorsement that it did not consider endorsing a Republican because “no Republican candidate responded to our invitation” is pure political nonsense.

In its announcement, the AFT also included the results of a member survey conducted over the phone between June 22 and 27, 2015. Based on 683 responses, AFT declares the following:

Overall, 60% of AFT members either self-identify as Democrats or self-identify as independent and say they will vote in the Democratic primaries. Following are some of the most important results among these AFT Democratic primary voters.

§ Hillary Clinton enjoys overwhelming support as AFT members’ first choice to be the Democratic presidential nominee. Fully two-thirds (67%) of Democratic primary voters pick Clinton, giving her a commanding 48-point lead over Bernie Sanders (19%) while O’Malley, Webb, and Chafee all receive no more than 1% of the vote. Clinton is the clear first choice among every division within AFT. [Emphasis added.]

One of the issues with this survey is that the data are already outdated. Another is that the data provide only a single snapshot in the continuous polling world of approaching presidential primary elections. Hillary’s “commanding” lead over Sanders is slowly closing in, with Clinton dropping and sanders rising. Consider the following posting by public opinion polling expert Kathy Frankovic, based on polling done July 4 – 6, 2015 (Click on image to enlarge):


From Frankovic:

With former Virginia Senator Jim Webb’s announcement last week, the Democrats now have five announced candidates (with Vice President Joe Biden as of now still on the sidelines).  On the GOP side, there are more than a dozen announced candidates, with another few likely to enter the contest in the next few weeks.   Republican support is scattered among a number of those candidates, with front-runners barely in double digits.  The smaller number of Democratic contenders produces a clear front-runner with majority support: former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.  However, this week, her closest challenger is closer than ever.  One in four Democrats now favor Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders.

Clinton’s support has dropped in the last few weeks as more candidates have entered the race, and as criticisms of her handling of private emails while she was Secretary of State have continued.  In last week’s poll, opinion of her handling of the terror attack on the U.S. Consulate in Benghazi, Libya matched her all-time low.

But Sanders is the only Clinton opponent who appears to have benefited.  His crowds have grown, along with his Democratic support.  When Democrats who are registered to vote are asked to choose only between Sanders and Clinton, Clinton holds a 35-point lead. [Emphasis added.]

Note that the 35-point lead that Clinton has involves asking Democrats if they had to choose between Clinton and Sanders, who would they choose?


So, considering the AFT survey result: whereas among AFT Democratic and likely-Independent primary voters surveyed between June 22 and 27, 2015, Clinton held a “commanding 48-point lead,” among Democratic voters surveyed by between July 4 and 6, 2015, that lead is not so “commanding,” with Clinton at 55% and Sanders at 24%– a 31-point lead.

And Sanders has no Benghazi situation and related mail scandal to plague him.

And there are still voters left to learn about Sanders. In contrast, when it comes to Clinton, Democratic and Independent voters feel like they know her (click on image to enlarge):



So, it seems that the timing of the inevitable AFT endorsement of Clinton is designed to boost her ratings, which overall happened to drop at an all-time low right as the AFT Clinton-endorsement survey was conducted (AFT survey: June 22-27, 2015; survey info below ends with June 27-29, 2015, polling) (click on image to enlarge):

KF terrorism-02


The above information on Clinton’s favorability with the general public is part of an article on public perceptions of terrorism Frankovic published on July 07, 2015. Again, Clinton’s handling of the Benghazi situation is having a bearing on public opinion. From Frankovic:

Concern about terrorism could be a factor in the 2016 presidential campaign. The latest release of additional emails from former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s private email account might matter. The public’s assessment of her handling of the 2012 attack on the American Consulate in Benghazi, Libya is now clearly negative. Only 29% this week approve of the way she handled the attack on the Benghazi Consulate, just about matching the lowest rating on this for Clinton since September 2014 (28%).

KF terrorism3

So, it looks like AFT’s publicized backing of Clinton on July 11 ,2015,  is an attempt to save her from Bernie Sanders, who is undoubtedly benefiting from public perceptions of Clinton’s poor handling of those Benghazi emails and will likely continue to rise in the polls and Clinton continues to drop.

How high Sanders will rise in the polls as we approach the Democratic primaries in early 2016 remains to be seen. However, Sanders has no Benghazi, and I think both Clinton and AFT are taking that truth seriously.

clinton sanders


Schneider is a southern Louisiana native, career teacher, trained researcher, and author of the ed reform whistle blower, A Chronicle of Echoes: Who’s Who In the Implosion of American Public Education.

She also has a second book, Common Core Dilemma: Who Owns Our Schools?, newly published on June 12, 2015.

both books


  1. Hillary’s alleged Benghazi issue is never going to go away, but it is no different than Kerry’s Swiftboat issue—both are alleged issues that were manufactured by the far right and both were as empty as the space between G. W. Bush’s ears.

    Kerry dropped the ball on the Swiftboat issue by deciding to ignore it because it seemed so vapid from his perspective after having fought in Vietnam and being close enough to bullets and shrapnel to receive flesh wounds several times in combat in addition to holding dying friends in his arms compared to G. W. Bush who used his family influence to keep out of the war like the brainless coward that he is.

    I’ve been in combat and I can tell you from first-hand experience that having bullets and shrapnel come close to you without slashing skin is still too close and Kerry’s encounters with rounds and shrapnel were much closer.

    Kerry should have fought back from day one. He didn’t. Surely, Hillary is smarter than that.

    • I like Kerry, but do you really think someone from the Forbes family would be in combat in Vietnam.

      • Kerry was the commanding officer on a swift boat in South Vietnam’s delta. I know someone who was the guy in charge of keeping the engines running. Swift boats were similar to PT boats but with very thin aluminum hulls. Rounds would go in one side of a swift boat and out the other unless one of the crew members got in the way. It was a risky combat situation racing around rivers bordered by thick jungles. The enemy could hide but the swift boat and its crew couldn’t.

        Kerry actually volunteered to go fight. I read quotes that he did it thinking it would be good for his political career.

      • Thank you Lloyd, that was interesting reading. (And, thank you for your service.)

  2. Laura H. Chapman permalink

    Lloyd, If I haven’t told you before, I value every one of your first person accounts and reminders of the different consequences that may flow from the exercise of moral courage, physical courage, and political courage. Same for Mercedes.

  3. I don’t think Benghazi and emails are the fears driving the AFTendorsement. I do believe the hope is to create some more distance in the lead over Sanders-but it’s because he has been consistent open, honest, and on-message for years. Hillary has the reputation (deserved or not) of being cautious, evasive…a more typical politician. Sanders has been saying the things that educators and working families have been dying to hear.

    Screw Benghazi and emails. The AFT move was to try to give some working family/organized labor street-cred to the most-likely-to-succeed wager, and attempt to pull away from the guy that walks the walk and talks the talk.. but scares away endorsement money (and would likely draw attack ads like never before seen). Watch for Hillary to start weaving Sanders-esque talking points into her speeches and ads. The Clinton team knows she has to, and so does AFT

  4. LAEducator permalink

    I love Bernie Sanders & I wish he could be president, but I believe it is much more likely that Hillary will ultimately win the nomination. I don’t think Democrats or Independents who would consider voting for Hillary see either Benghazi or the emails as a problem. I would vote for Bernie, a Socialist, for president, but I don’t believe a majority of Americans would do so. I do hope that his growing popularity will continue to push Hillary further left. I like Bill & Hillary, but they have too many billionaire friends like Bill Gates for me to be comfortable. Her insistence that Common Core is merely suffering from a bad brand is frightening. Still, I will certainly vote for Hillary against any of the 16 candidates currently in the Republican Clown car.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: