Skip to content

BREAKING: Post-Katrina New Orleans Schools Costs More, Admin Salaries a Main Reason

January 17, 2017

On January 17, 2017, the Education Research Alliance of New Orleans (ERA) released a report entitled, “Does School Reform Equal Spending Reform?”

The short answer is no, and those who push to decentralize a school district in the name of “choice” should be prepared to spend more if for no other reason that a loss of economy of scale– in other words, of paying for the loss of centralized operations.

Then there are issues related to those running the decentralized schools– the administrators.

In the ERA report, these individuals were the principal reason (pun intended) for the finding that post-Katrina New Orleans publicly funded education (which is now chiefly done by charter schools with their own charter management orgs.) costs 13 percent more ($1,358) per pupil than it does in comparable Louisiana school districts– districts with comparable per-pupil spending pre-Katrina.

The greatest increase for New Orleans schools goes to its administrators, as ERA reports:

Spending on administration in New Orleans’ publicly funded schools increased by 66% ($699 per student) relative to the comparison group, far more than the overall spending increase. Of this increase, 52% ($363 per student) is due to a rise in total administrative salaries. Roughly one-third of the increase in administrative salaries is due to hiring more administrators, and the remainder is due to higher average salaries per administrator.

In an attempt to explain the possible reasons for the astounding administrative costs in New Orleans’ post-Katrina *publicly funded schools* (I love that term; it’s so politically disarming), ERA offers the following, for starters:

One possible reaction to the higher salaries for administrators is that charter school educators are using the reforms to enrich themselves. However, it is worth noting that charter schools are more likely to hire educators with degrees from elite colleges and school leaders with business backgrounds, people who typically earn high salaries outside of education. The higher salaries may partly reflect the other professional opportunities available to the new educator workforce.

Comprehensive audits examining the degree to which those administrators might just be “enriching themselves” via the public coffer are long overdue. However, I’ll set that aside for now and focus on the draw of the elite-educated, business-backgrounded admin who is paid more, well, because business people have greater professional opportunity than those who might lack such ambitious reach and settle for state-school degrees in education.

The problem with paying juicy admin salaries in “publicly funded” schools is that doing so is not sustainable. Indeed, no school can survive without teachers, and ERA has discovered that even as post-Katrina admin costs rose notably, instructional costs declined by $706 per student in New Orleans– which includes drops in staff benefits ($353 per student) and staff salaries ($233 per student).

Another noteworthy issue is that New Orleans schools have become dependent upon a supply of less-experienced teachers– which ERA posits might explain those ballooning admin costs:

The hiring of additional managers might be related to the reliance on younger teachers who no doubt need more active leadership and professional development. The substantive issue is whether this alternative model—trading off more managers for lower teacher experience—is good for students. From what we know so far, the system is working to improve measureable student outcomes.

Even if the New Orleans reforms are judged positively, however, it is not clear whether this model is sustainable financially. There are signs that interest in New Orleans is abating among younger teachers and growing concern about the constant churn of teachers who do not plan to stay or make teaching a career here. The state government is also in dire financial straits and may eventually have to either reduce spending or force charter schools to pay into the state pension system. Something will have to give.

ERA’s point about New Orleans schools improving “based upon measurable student outcomes” is a loaded statement. If nothing else, there are no “measurable” outcomes on students who disappear and who cannot be traced because a decentralized system has no means of effectively accounting for all of its students.

As of 2016, the New Orleans Miracle continues to be a mixed bag. Most New Orleans publicly-funded schools are charter schools, and the school grades are heavily C, D, and F. (School performance scores can be accessed here.)

The high schools taken over by the state in 2005 have yet to break a 17 composite ACT score.

But these *successes* aside, not only is the fiscal sustainability of charter-portfolio New Orleans in question; according to ERA, the young, churning teacher population is showing a waning interest in investing a couple years of their lives in New Orleans’ publicly-funded classrooms. Indeed, Teach for America (TFA), a primary supplier of temporary teachers, is itself facing recruiting problems.

Temp teachers are becoming scarce in miraculous New Orleans.

And when it comes to the Louisiana state budget woes— forget about it.

New Orleans schools might just have to bow to economy of scale and return to the Orleans Parish School Board (OPSB), not as a “portfolio district” of separate charter schools, but reunited as a traditional school system for the sake of survival.

The ERA report offers more info than noted in this post. It is worth the read.

shocked-dollar

__________________________________________________________

Released July 2016– Book Three:

School Choice: The End of Public Education? 

school choice cover  (Click image to enlarge)

Schneider is a southern Louisiana native, career teacher, trained researcher, and author of both A Chronicle of Echoes: Who’s Who In the Implosion of American Public Education and Common Core Dilemma: Who Owns Our Schools?.

both books

Don’t care to buy from Amazon? Purchase my books from Powell’s City of Books instead.

3 Comments
  1. WOW Mercedes……looks like the New Orleans miracle appears to be spreading to other states like a plague. These “other” states are landlocked so were not hit by a hurricane……on second thought – they were hit by a hurricane – they were hit by “Hurricane Jeb or Hurrican FEE/FFF” whichever you prefer because they are both dangerous, deadly, and harmful. Jeb Bush (through his foundations – FEE (Foundation for Excellence in Education) and/or FFF (Foundation for Florida’s Future) continue to spread his harmful and hurtful policies like tying teacher evaluations to high-stakes test scores (like here in FL – the FSA), mandatory 3rd grade retention (there was a lawsuit filed last year that is still being fought in the courts), and his infamous “A+ Plan” where they grade schools based off those high-stakes test scores. The teachers are forced to teach to the test due to their fear of losing their jobs if god forbid their school gets a “C’, “D’ or “F” rating. And of course we have the huge push to convert our public schools to for-profit charter schools. We have had an onslaught of charter schools led by Jonathan Hage who is Jeb’s partner in crime going back to 1992. These “policies” are like poison and do absolutely NOTHING to help our kids. The money being transferred to the bank accounts of these “for-profit” charter schools who have absolutely zero accountability or transparency is sickening. Our kids are suffering and these charter school leaders are becoming extremely wealthly. And just as a side note – Jeb is friends with DeVos who sits on his board of FEE.

  2. Charter schools are not alone in facing an overabundance of non-teaching personnel. In my own experience with fund-garnering school reforms inside a test-fanatic district, bureaucratic bloat was one of NCLB’s earliest progeny. http://www.ciedieaech.wordpress.com/2015/10/10/factoring-in-the-testing-factor

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: